« Previous page |
Next page » |
This week's winner of the "Well, duh" award goes to this morning's article in the New York Times, "Lobbyists Oppose Efforts to Impose New Restrictions," which for all intents and purposes should have been titled, "Lobbyists Lobby Against Lobbying Reform."
"Any behavior you can think of," says Mark Kristal, a professor of psychology from the State University of New York at Buffalo, "somebody, somewhere, has done it." That includes placenta eating, though Kristal is pretty sure that it has never been a common practice in any extant human culture. But while I was working on a recent piece for Slate about patients taking home keepsakes from surgery, I kept coming across stories about the practice, known as placentophagy (Wikipedia).
Gelf previously has taken issue with Metro, one of New York's free daily newspapers aimed at commuters. But it was Metro's generally superior rival, amNewYork, that ran a front-page headline Tuesday on par with the New York Post's Kerry/Gephardt ticket (Smoking Gun). Quoth amNewYork: "The prez vows fed abortion ban will be overturnedmany New Yorkers disagree."
Among the highlights of this week's edition of Oops, Gelf's quasi-weekly round-up of media corrections: Holocaust numbers; that 'Friends' apartment; and two longtime journalists get fired, prompting questions about overreaching from the plagiarism police. Here's one of our favorite corrections this week:
Pherotones are the controversial brainchild of Myra Vanderhood, an iconoclastic intimacy researcher whose findings have alienated her from mainstream science. If you hear a phone ring with one of these sounds, you will be under the influence of a love potion. That's the story at pherotones.com; but maybe it's all just a stealth marketing campaign by McKinney Silver, as several commenters at Makezine.com have argued. At the suggestion of a spokeswoman for Durham, North Carolina-based McKinney Silver, Gelf instant-messaged with Dr. Vanderhood. We'll leave it to you to decide whether you should soon put on earmuffs when within earshot of cellphones, or instead install a bullshit-detector when surfing new websites.
In this week's edition of Blurb Racketthe Gelf feature in which we take a close look at those critic blurbs that are a fixture of ads for moviessee breakdowns of blurbs for The White Countess, The Ringer, The Producers, and more. This week's winner of the Bogus Blurb of the Week award comes in an ad for Hostel:
When New York Times music critic Kelefa Sanneh saw Lil Wayne and Robin Thicke team up for an impressive version of the song "Shooter" on The Tonight Show, he was inspired to write an article about what he terms "cross-under hits." As Sanneh sees it, this is one of many music videos that start out as part of big-budget television, get picked up on the web, and "return to life as underground hits." But he misses the point.
Doubleday didn't bother to fact-check a best-seller, so the Smoking Gun did it for them. James Frey chronicled his rehab from drug and alcohol addiction in A Million Little Pieces, a purported nonfiction memoir that has sold more than 3.5 million copies and was chosen by Oprah Winfrey for her book club (populated by perhaps a million little viewers). Many of Frey's colorful characters were reported dead, conveniently, in the book's postcript, so the Smoking Gun trained its investigative sights on his self-reported crimes and detailed a few days ago extensive problems with Frey's account. Why didn't Doubleday's Nan A. Talese imprint catch the problems? Because books generally aren't fact-checked.
As every good journalist knows, three's a trend. This helps explain why the New York Times's Week in Review article about Farris Hassan, the 16-year old student who traveled to Iraq, also mentions two other male teenage risk-takers from years past as it attempts to weave a narrative that links adolescent derring-do stunts to… well, it's unclear.
In this week's edition of Zooming In, Gelf's quasi-weekly round-up of undercovered local stories from around the world: Very hungry eagles; an ad of questionable taste; and an ironic citizen-journalism blurb. One of our favorite stories this week concerns the Czechs' official baby-name minder.
« Previous page |
Next page » |
The Gelflog brings you all the same sports, media & world coverage you’ve come to love from Gelf Magazine, but shorter and faster. If you’d like, subscribe to the Gelflog feed.
Subscribe to the Gelflog RSS