Education | Food | Government

October 3, 2005

How to Beat Obesity

Use the same tactics that have been successful against smoking.

Sarah Arnquist

America has a weight problem. A stroll through the local mall or middle school is proof enough that adults and children are packing on extra pounds. Public-health experts call the obesity epidemic hitting the US a public-health crisis that threatens to shorten the lifespan of today's youth and bankrupt the health care system we all rely on. Curbing the epidemic requires going beyond gimmick diets and changing social norms like California, New York, and other progressive states have done around smoking and tobacco use. America must reconstruct environments that promote—not discourage—healthy living.

Courtesy Angr
Extra fat can lead to health problems later in life.
About 60 percent of American adults are categorized as "overweight," meaning that they have a body mass index (BMI) of over 25 kg/m², and about one in three are categorized as "obese," meaning that they have a BMI of over 30 kg/m². More than one quarter of American children are overweight and unfit. All that extra weight increases the risk for chronic conditions like hypertension and diabetes. One in three newborn babies will develop diabetes (CDC), and for the first time since the Great Depression, the youngest generation will have a shorter lifespan than its parents because of obesity's detrimental effects (PRB).

Whose fault is it that we're getting fatter? Is it a lack of individual willpower? Can personal laziness and gluttony account for the soaring rates of obesity? Health experts say no. They point out that human genes have not changed in the last 30 years, but our surrounding environments have. We've created communities that discourage physical activity and push high-fat, high-sugar foods at us all hours of the day. "It's a direct result of public policy," Harold Goldstein, executive director of the California Center for Public Health Advocacy, tells Gelf. "The environment has changed to seduce us to eating more unhealthy foods and being less active."

America has more sugary and fatty foods available than ever before, and we exercise less than ever before. Scientifically, that's our problem. We're consuming more energy than we burn off and so our bodies store it as fat. Food lures us at every meeting, event, and activity. It bombards us on the television, on billboards, and in magazines. Humans are genetically predisposed to crave high fat, sugary foods, Goldstein says, and, well, those foods are everywhere.

Willpower only goes so far. Our culture needs to change its approach to food. We need to invert the economic structure that makes potato chips cheaper than strawberries. We need to subsidize school nutrition programs with money for fresh fruits and vegetables instead of paying farmers not to farm their land. Society must quit blaming the fat people and start blaming the government leaders and businesses that create unhealthy environments, Goldstein says. Shaming people because they are overweight will get society nowhere. People must support one another to make a healthier America, says Susan Foerster, chief of the Cancer Prevention and Nutrition Section of the California Department of Health. "You really can't do it alone," she says. "You need environmental support. You need social support."

But where should the changes start? Multiple factors contribute to America's weight problem. Many children have virtually unregulated access to television and videogames. Parents want their children to stay sedentary inside instead of running around outside because they live in unsafe neighborhoods. Food and beverage companies spend billions to advertise their products to young children. The companies hope to hook kids on sugary sodas and fatty French fries at an early age. Communities favor the automobile and discourage walking and bicycling. Many places lack safe parks and walking trails.

Underfunded schools share the blame for seizing lucrative soda contracts to fund their sports programs. But can local schools be blamed for cutting out physical-education classes because their students need more time in math and reading to pass the tests required by No Child Left Behind legislation?

Goldstein and Foerster say every category of American society must share the blame and the responsibility to initiate change. It's in society's best interest to do so. "[Obesity] is eroding our productivity and bottom line," Foerster says.

The food and beverage companies hide behind lobby groups with Orwellian names like the Center for Consumer Freedom (Wikipedia). They denounce the strict school nutrition laws passed in California and attempts to limit fast food in communities as "unAmerican." They preach free enterprise and consumer rights and worry about their bottom line. The arguments sound very familiar to the public-health experts who led the anti-tobacco campaign through the 1980s and 90s. It took decades of educating the public about tobacco use and second-hand smoke, but people can no longer smoke in most public places in California. In 2004, California's adult smoking rate reached a historic low at 15.4% compared with 22.8% in 1988, when the state launched its antitobacco program (California Department of Health Services in PDF).

Super Size Me
Super Size Me has helped to spark a national debate about who is to blame for skyrocketing obesity levels.
Awareness is growing. Two huge reasons for this, Eric Schlosser's book Fast Food Nation and Morgan Spurlock's documentary Super Size Me brought the heavy message right to where Americans like best to be—their couches. Both illustrate the economics, policy, and industry driving America's expanding waistlines, and both have already gotten results. California passed landmark legislation in September to kick out soda and junk food from the state's schools. Great Britain passed similar laws last week (BBC).

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger called a health and obesity summit in September where he asked business leaders to take a step toward making California a healthier place. Businesses can save money by promoting healthy living. They can stock vending machines and fridges with healthy snacks. They can sponsor gym memberships and encourage nutrition programs. If fewer employees are overweight, the company's productivity will increase and their health insurance and workers' compensation payouts will decrease. Some minor, inexpensive changes could lead to big-time savings.

Local city officials must take a new approach to designing their communities. They must think like walkers and bikers and plan mixed-use neighborhoods with safe trails and access to grocery stores. Cities should ensure children have safe parks to play in and paths to walk to school. Schools must bring back physical education.

Sounds impossible, right? Well, people would have roared hysterically 20 years ago at the thought that no one could smoke in restaurants or bars in California. Cultural norms can shift. The success of the antismoking campaign proves that. Now it's time to apply those same principles to obesity.

Post a comment

Comment Rules

The following HTML is allowed in comments:
Bold: <b>Text</b>
Italic: <i>Text</i>
<a href="URL">Text</a>


- Government
- posted on Apr 27, 08

In your next article have more ways to solve the problem and not just bashing the Particapants of the greater issue of obesity. have more facts on the PROBLEMS, FASTFOOD CONTRIBUTERS, and the SOLUTION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! please and thank you

- Government
- posted on Apr 04, 09
Bonnie and Jack from California


Here is a web site you may like. It deals with obesity and what we can do to help our
children make better choices. VendNatural is installing vending machines that sell healthy, organic and
nutritious foods at schools. Now kids have a choice! I think that as we give our children and grandchildren
choices along with education they will see how important it is to stay healthy and active. Please look at this
web site. You will be surprised!


- Government
- posted on Oct 12, 10

american people need to loose weight !

Article by Sarah Arnquist

Contact this author